A Look at DCDC Boost Converters

We were looking for a 3V to 7-8V DCDC Boost converter module recently and had a particularly hard time finding a suitable candidate. The current requirements were 0.6A continuous and 2.5A peak. Here are few of the options we considered.

Option 1 – XL6009 Module
Option 2 – LM2577 Module
Option 3 – LM2587 Module

All of these are marketed to work in an input voltage as low as 3V.

Here are some screencaptures of sales pages from Aliexpress sellers.

Option 1 – XL6009 Boost Converter Module Aliexpress sales page
Option 2 – LM2577 Boost Converter Module Aliexpress sales page
Option 3 – LM2587 Boost Converter Module Aliexpress sales page

And here are screencaptures of resellers who are also marketing their wide input voltage range.

Option 1 – XL6009 Boost Converter Module Reseller Page
Option 2 – LM2577 Boost Converter Module Reseller Page
Option 3 – LM2587 Boost Converter Module Reseller Page

On bench testing using a power supply and discharger, we found that Option 1 and Option 2 did not meet the desired specifications.

Websites are falsely claiming their wide input range all the way down to 3V.

Option 1 – XL6009 based module goes into thermal runaway around 3.5V input, and is not able to maintain a steady 7.2V output at 400mA.

Option 1 – XL6009 Module being tested

Option 2 – In the LM2577 based module, we found that the LCD starts to flicker around 4.9V input even at no load! This module definitely does not meet the marketed specifications of 3V input.

Option 2 – LM2577 Module being tested

Out of the options we considered, we found that Option 3 was the best out of the lot. It does not go into thermal runaway even at 2.8V input, and operates decently well up to 3.4-3.5V input maintaining a 7.2V output at 500mA continuous. In our testing conditions, we did notice however that it the module gets considerably hot during operation, and with electrolytic caps on the board we don’t recommend running the board at high temperatures. We would recommend adding heat sinks to the LM2587 IC for proper heat dissipation and long term use.


Range Estimation for an Electric Vehicle

Range estimation is an important parameter for putting an Electric Vehicle on the road. Certification tests require disclosure of estimated range at different conditions, and more importantly users of the vehicle make daily decisions about their driving based on the amount of range left as calculated by the vehicle itself.A lot of parameters can be...
Continue Reading

Dry Coated Electrode – Tesla’s Acquisition of Maxwell

If you’ve taken the Battery Masterclass, you know that the electrode material which includes the binder and the active material are mixed into a slurry before they are applied evenly on the current collector to form an electrode.  Courtesy of LG Chem The process of manufacturing electrodes needs energy, water and a lot of floor...
Continue Reading

My Takeaways from Tesla’s Battery Day event

Tabless architecture cells The new cell will be 46mm in diameter and 80mm in heightLaser padded the existing foils to enable dozens of connections into the active materialElectron has to travel less distanceBetter power to weight ratioTabs slow down rate of production5x energy, 16% range increase, 6x power [AG comments]-> A problem with larger diameter...
Continue Reading
2 Responses

Leave a Reply

error: Content is protected